The Other Parts of Rowing (TOPOR) IV – Aquatic Mishaps

[April 10, 1933] “There Goes the Oar – George Binehorn, U.C. Jayvee bow man, ‘catches crab’ at finish of brilliant race. He reaches, trying to regain control of the oar which trails beside the shell, while the crew rhythm goes berserk, and Washington goes on to win.”
5 May 2020

By Thomas E. Weil

Rowing qua rowing is to most HTBS Types the act of attempting to achieve symphony in motion in a competitive context.  But even that core act takes place within a smorgasbord of other activities. This, another in HTBS’s Dry Season Bottom-of-the-Barrel Series, is the fourth in a mini-series illustrating some of those other elements of rowing, as depicted by several decades of randomly collected news photos, images that demonstrate the insatiable appetite of the popular press at a time when journalism was interested not just in the act of rowing itself, but also in the bits and pieces that make up the greater tapestry of the sport.

Any number of catastrophes can befall a crew in the midst of a race. Catching a crab, shown above (note the charming practice of the supplemental illustration), is probably the most common. The mid-race collapse of a rower, and collisions (with a competitor, another craft, flotsam, or a buoy or pier) are not infrequent. But the most dramatic event must be a sinking, and this piece captures some of that particularly waterlogged aspect of the sport.

[April 22, 1935] “This four at Sydney, Australia went out for a practice row. The waves were high on the river. Soon the coxswain was crying for ten hard ones to get the boat home before the boat sank. The picture shows the shell and oarsmen just before waves claimed them. All were saved.”
Most of the wire photos heretofore displayed in the TOPOR posts have been U.S. or UK images, but, as shown in this scene from Sydney, a shell sinking, having a pathetic drama of their own, appear to have claimed more international newsworthiness and attention. One of two classic poses, displayed here, is that which shows the swamped rowers seated at rest in their submerged craft.

[May 18, 1957] “They Left their Bailing Cups Behind – Waseda university [sic] oarsmen were way behind (top) in their 26th annual regatta with their cross-town Tokyo rivals, Keio in a 6000 meter race on the Sumida river [sic] when fate, tempered by a cloudburst, 22 mph winds and bailing cups, came to their rescue. The Keio crew had no bailing cups, Waseda did. At 3700 meters the Keio oarsmen rowed right into the river (below). The Waseda crew went on to win with half the crew using aluminum bailing cups to keep their shell from following the fate of Keio’s.”
The other classic view, as portrayed here in this contest from Tokyo, is the dynamic sinking, showing the shell going under the waves, which is particularly impressive when even the oars have disappeared from sight. This event underscores another aspect of racing in trying conditions – being sufficiently prepared. Waseda thought to bring bailing cups, while Keio didn’t. Almost 60 years later, Harvard, carrying four pumps, dove into the Thames shortly after the start, while Yale, carrying eight pumps, safely completed the four-mile course.

[April 2, 1970] “Someone zigged when they should have zagged – someone, suspicion has it ‘twas cockswain [sic], forgot to check oarlocks … when they lifted shell, balance was tipped and into drink it went.”
Much more embarrassing than a sinking underway is an incident at the dock.  It is not clear from the somewhat confusing caption what actually transpired (did the boat flip when rowers got in without having fastened their oarlocks?), but any view of a torrent of water sluicing out of a shell suggests that some form of aquatic accident must have occurred.

[June 14, 1970] “Mime of Ancient Mariner – Silhouetted woefully against the sky, a Boston University oarsman resembles a shipwrecked mariner as he uses a shoe to bail out his swamped shell. The Terrier’s junior varsity crew was starting its heat in the college rowing championships at Syracuse, N.Y., when high winds nearly scuttled the craft. They finished dead last.”
This image suggests a certain theatricality of the absurd – the dilemma, in which the shell is clearly not swamped (were it actually submerged, bailing by any means would be futile) is far from dire, and the means of salvation is a common shoe, but finishing DFL in any contest is sufficiently traumatic to warrant our sympathy.

[June 1, 1971] “One Way to Lose the Race – Members of the Marist College freshman eight crew squad sit patiently as their shell slowly sinks into Lake Onondaga, near Syracuse, during the second heat of the National Intercollegiate Rowing Championships, Thursday. The small Poughkeepsie, N.Y. college was participating in the regatta for the first time.”
Half a century later, as more attention is given to the potential for adverse conditions at rowing venues, changes include having abandoned the often unpredictable and inhospitable Lake Onondaga for more protected sites, thus reducing the likelihood of such swampings. Of more immediate interest here, however, might be the paramount and disturbing question of the fates that may have befallen the three of the eight rowers who are no longer visible …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.